Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 21 to 30 of 40

Thread: Greencard via Employment

  1. #21
    Forum Hero Alex_3112's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Туц Оукыун
    Posts
    12,761

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    The corporates are unhappy with the H-1B visa situation WHATEVER the limit is - 65K or 120K. They want the cap GONE. Period.
    Oh well, there would be quite a different kind of unhappiness.
    Imagine you are going for a job that pays 65K. You'd like to get 120K, but you can swallow your pride. However, as you start working, you are getting actual paychecks for 45K! Would you keep quiet about it now? ;)

    USCIS may try to keep visa numbers down all they want. But using H1B cap as pretext for not accepting the applications - while the cap is not actually filled - would be illegal.

    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    What field? Were advanced degrees in such field typical?

    In Chemistry (that I can totally speak of) even for an M.S. person it's hard to secure H-1B; for B.A. or B.S. I wouldn't even try!
    IT = Information Technology

    I imagine in science situation is quite different. Not so many openings for BS candidates and not so many for MS either. In IT, actually, we have to deal with the opposite type of requests: "Please prove that this position requires MS degree."

  2. #22
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    2,836

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    USCIS may try to keep visa numbers down all they want. But using H1B cap as pretext for not accepting the applications - while the cap is not actually filled - would be illegal.
    Yes, but if they have any legal chance to get around it - they WILL! They weren't super accomodating even before September 11, 2001. The worst of them was, actually, in 2002, when INS was reformed into BCIS under DHS. A lot of the INS workers were laid off (and in 2002, if your recall, the job situation was just as bad as now), so they were especially in the "denial mood".

    Now there is this damn crisis - what would you expect? Extra kindness???

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    IT = Information Technology

    I imagine in science situation is quite different. Not so many openings for BS candidates and not so many for MS either. In IT, actually, we have to deal with the opposite type of requests: "Please prove that this position requires MS degree."
    OK. BTW, what is the meaning of such request? Do they imply that the candidate may be overqualified for the job? Well, this can hasppen, too! In science it's just not so frequent; usually the other way around...

  3. #23
    Forum Hero Alex_3112's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Туц Оукыун
    Posts
    12,761

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    Yes, but if they have any legal chance to get around it - they WILL!
    The legality of such practice is questionable at best. They may deny an application, fine, but they can not refuse to accept it without legal reason. In cap is not actually filled, then no such reason exist.
    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    OK. BTW, what is the meaning of such request? Do they imply that the candidate may be overqualified for the job?
    This goes back to "US candidates" clause. Suppose, company advertised for a position that requires MS degree, and nobody qualified responded. Then, USCIS suggests that the position actually requires BS degree, and some US candidates may become qualified.

  4. #24
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    2,836

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    The legality of such practice is questionable at best. They may deny an application, fine, but they can not refuse to accept it without legal reason. In cap is not actually filled, then no such reason exist.
    How often do you have to go to an immigration court to resolve such sort of matter?

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    This goes back to "US candidates" clause. Suppose, company advertised for a position that requires MS degree, and nobody qualified responded. Then, USCIS suggests that the position actually requires BS degree, and some US candidates may become qualified.
    That's an example! See, they [the USCIS] do ALL THEY CAN to issue as few work visas as possible.

  5. #25
    Forum Hero Alex_3112's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Туц Оукыун
    Posts
    12,761

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    How often do you have to go to an immigration court to resolve such sort of matter?
    In wouldn't be an immigration court. This case would go straight to Federal court, or would be simply lobbied through the Congress.
    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    That's an example! See, they [the USCIS] do ALL THEY CAN to issue as few work visas as possible.
    So what? Your employer would like to pay you as little as possible. As long as it's legal, he can. But if he starts paying 45K instead of agreed upon 65K, he'll get into trouble.

  6. #26
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    2,836

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    In wouldn't be an immigration court. This case would go straight to Federal court, or would be simply lobbied through the Congress.
    I did not mean rules, regulations, quotas, etc. I meant an INDIVIDUAL case. If denied, have you, or anyone on behalf of your institution, ever tried to contest it in the local immigration court?

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    So what? Your employer would like to pay you as little as possible. As long as it's legal, he can.
    I guess, it can't be less than the minimum salary as mandated by law... :white:

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    But if he starts paying 45K instead of agreed upon 65K, he'll get into trouble.
    Can you sue the employer? (I thought all you can do in such situation is quit... Unless you have a specific contract with a certain salary specification, of course - then the emmployer can't pay you a penny less, I suppose)

  7. #27
    Forum Hero Alex_3112's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Туц Оукыун
    Posts
    12,761

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    I did not mean rules, regulations, quotas, etc. I meant an INDIVIDUAL case. If denied, have you, or anyone on behalf of your institution, ever tried to contest it in the local immigration court?
    Sure, this is common in cases like asylum.
    Unfortunately, I have no first-hand knowledge of appeals in H1-B case denials - I have no knowledge about such denials either.

    Quote Originally Posted by Amex1 View Post
    Unless you have a specific contract with a certain salary specification, of course - then the emmployer can't pay you a penny less, I suppose)
    Cap of 65K visas set by the Congress is specific enough, right?

  8. #28
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    2,836

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    Cap of 65K visas set by the Congress is specific enough, right?
    And here is the loophole: by April 29, 2008, they had received a number of applications, far greater than 65,000. So, they randomly selected 65,000 of all applications, and... denied some (I don't know how many) on the grounds of "underqualified" or "overqualified". I don't know how many, but de-facto they issue less than the cap allows.

    Such situation irritates me just as much as the stupid "section 214(b) of INA"

  9. #29

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by Alex_3112 View Post
    The legality of such practice is questionable at best. They may deny an application, fine, but they can not refuse to accept it without legal reason. In cap is not actually filled, then no such reason exist.

    This goes back to "US candidates" clause. Suppose, company advertised for a position that requires MS degree, and nobody qualified responded. Then, USCIS suggests that the position actually requires BS degree, and some US candidates may become qualified.
    Потому что правила приравнивают каждые 3 года опыта в сфере как 1 год учёбы. Т.е. если Мастерс занимает скажем 2 года то Бачелор + 6 лет опыта = эквивалент Мастеру. Примерно так. Unfortunately it works both ways whether petitioner likes it or not.

  10. #30
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    2,836

    Default Re: Greencard via Employment

    Quote Originally Posted by zgorynych View Post
    Потому что правила приравнивают каждые 3 года опыта в сфере как 1 год учёбы. Т.е. если Мастерс занимает скажем 2 года то Бачелор + 6 лет опыта = эквивалент Мастеру. Примерно так. Unfortunately it works both ways whether petitioner likes it or not.
    Don't get me started on the USCIS rules in general. They are sometiles... no, not just weird, but WILD! As I said in a parallel branch, it makes no sense that some DV-winner can become a US Immigrant, and an Assistant Professor at Stanford, holding O-1 visa, can't...

    And BTW, whose "clone" am I? :spam:

Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Russian America Top. Рейтинг ресурсов Русской Америки. Terms of Service | Privacy Policy Рейтинг@Mail.ru