Page 4 of 11 FirstFirst 1234567891011 LastLast
Results 31 to 40 of 105

Thread: Birthright Citizenship

  1. #31
    Banned Chukcha's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Oc
    Posts
    2,576

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    Дети при том, что их родители не платят ни копейки налогов, но их дети законные граждане и пользуются всеми возможными льготами и пособиями. И их семьи считаются ниже уровня нищеты, ведь официальный заработок их родителей - $0.

  2. #32
    Forum Master
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    489

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    Quote Originally Posted by Chukcha
    Дети при том, что их родители не платят ни копейки налогов, но их дети законные граждане и пользуются всеми возможными льготами и пособиями. И их семьи считаются ниже уровня нищеты, ведь официальный заработок их родителей - $0.
    Да, это и имелось в виду. Просто стали писать, что мол я против этого закона, потому что детишки умрут с голоду.:D Кстати одна из причина почему закон частично не инфорсывается эти детишки и приводятся.Мол мы не можем депортировать родителей граждан США, сидящих на дотациях. Отсюда и желание его изменить. Лишить их как говориться стимула.

  3. #33

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    Quote Originally Posted by elfy
    aga :grum: :34:
    but seriously, I can bet you 10 bucks there is no amnesty coming any time soon,
    Deal :-)

    I am not talking about the possibility that illegals will get a temporary work visa for 3 years with the requirement to go back to their country after that, I am talking about the real amnesty

    What's "unreal" about even this thing? Sure, they would prefer to just get a GC right away... but this is a great way to reward their total disregard to the laws too, isn't it?
    Waaaay better then granting their babies citizenship at birth anyway.

  4. #34
    seaman seaman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    PA
    Posts
    8,026

  5. #35
    Forum Master
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    489

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    This article is so ridiculous I don’t even know where to begin… I‘ll start debating some of the points from it. Here’s one:

    ”Key among these reasons is that doing so simply won't accomplish what the anti-immigrants suppose. Illegal workers will still come to this country. Those here will not leave.”- Oh, it looks now that they are FOR enforcing the immigration laws, right? Then why do they oppose ANY law that would strengthen the border and deport illegals? Better yet, why don’t THEY come up with an enforcement measure they think would be adequate? :confused:

    Here’s another:
    ”They come to work. No matter how draconian the law, they will still come as long as there is work here and not there”- How do you know? We’ve never had draconian laws on the books. Or have we? We already have plenty saying that an illegal should be deported. Are they draconian? According to them, yes. They even opposed the latest enforcement-only bill. It was too draconian in their opinion.

    ”Effective immigration reform must rise above such punitive sentiments. Denying citizenship to people born here will tell the world that in the never-ending struggle between inclusion and exclusion in this country, intolerance has won.” -Which world (countries) do you exactly have in mind? Some European? Almost all of them don’t have birthright citizenship.
    Some others like Ireland whose people ended the birthright law in 2004 by voting it out of their constitution by an overwhelming majority? Or Australia, England, New Zealand who had successfully repealed it themselves?

  6. #36

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    Quote Originally Posted by Bumazhka
    ”Key among these reasons is that doing so simply won't accomplish what the anti-immigrants suppose. Illegal workers will still come to this country. Those here will not leave.”- Oh, it looks now that they are FOR enforcing the immigration laws, right? Then why do they oppose ANY law that would strengthen the border and deport illegals? Better yet, why don’t THEY come up with an enforcement measure they think would be adequate? :confused:
    This seems to be beyond the point though - the fact that some lefties are hypocrites (which I don't debate) does not by itself really invalidate the point you hughlighted, does it? ;-)
    I, for one, agree with it - don't see any reason whatsoever why, for example, somebody who is already here illegally all of a sudden would decide to leave, just because he'd get told that if he ever has a baby, (s)he won't be a citizen...

  7. #37
    Forum Master
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    489

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    Quote Originally Posted by foma
    I, for one, agree with it - don't see any reason whatsoever why, for example, somebody who is already here illegally all of a sudden would decide to leave, just because he'd get told that if he ever has a baby, (s)he won't be a citizen...
    Off course the amendment won’t force those who are already here out. But at least it will tarnish the lure of coming here illegally to give birth just to “anchor” themselves, don’t you think? It’s partially to discourage future waves of illegal immigrants is all I am saying..

  8. #38

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    Quote Originally Posted by Bumazhka
    But at least it will tarnish the lure of coming here illegally to give birth just to ”anchor” themselves, don’t you think?
    Not really...
    I just don't believe that there really is that large a number of people who come here, intentionally with a sole (or main... or just one of - whatever) purpose of giving birth to a new citizen, and that would not come if it was not possible.

    They are coming here simply because the life is so much better here than whereever they are from, and because it is such an easy thing to do, it would almost be stupid not to.
    The laws are not enforced, the wages are good (compared to what they make at home), the food is cheap, the schools and hospitals are free, and every few years there is an amnesty, and you get your GC ... why not to come???

    Just because your kid won't be a citizen? Who cares!

  9. #39
    Forum Master
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    489

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    Quote Originally Posted by foma
    Not really...
    I just don't believe that there really is that large a number of people who come here, intentionally with a sole (or main... or just one of - whatever) purpose of giving birth to a new citizen, and that would not come if it was not possible.
    Then here is what I want you to do…;)
    Next time if you happen to come across a person from Mexico(illegal preferably but not necessarily) (s)he just needs to be from Mexico ask if it’s a well known fact down south used by them to come and give birth here. I personally asked one of them. His answer was “o yea”. Not only did they themselves come here illegally and have American citizens in their family now but they’ve actually tried to bring some of their close relatives (who were at the child-bearing age at the time) to stay and procreate on US soil.
    In short, ask just for the heck of it to really see the scope of abuse of this amendment.
    Mexicans by the way are not alone in this. Wealthy South Koreans too are coming here for the sole purpose of being in labor here.

  10. #40

    Default Re: Birthright Citizenship

    That is not the right question to ask though, is it? :-)
    You try asking them if they would still come here, even if their babies could not become citizens (or if they were sterile, ot could not give birth ... whatever).

    I am not disputing that they know this fact, and like it... I am just saying it is not at all the determining factor in their decision to come and stay.

    So, if we were serious to really try and do something about illegal immigration (which I am sure we are not BTW), this citizenship thing should be the last to look at.
    We should start with securing the borders, enforcing the employment and tax laws, denying financial benefits to the illegals, including education and medicinem, making it painfully clear, that there will not be any amnesty any more, not even for "guest workers" etc, etc.

    If we were serious about improving the situation, we would do that... and then changing the constitution would simply not be necessary... and if it still is, we should change it to completely get rid of the stupid territorial factor - a child of citizen should be a citizen, and that's it!

    Wealthy South Koreans too are coming here for the sole purpose of being in labor here.
    Illegally? I don't think so...
    Besides, what do you think they motive is? I doubt it is to collect welfare, since they are "wealthy"...
    It looks like a totally different issue to me.

Page 4 of 11 FirstFirst 1234567891011 LastLast

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Russian America Top. Рейтинг ресурсов Русской Америки. Terms of Service | Privacy Policy Рейтинг@Mail.ru